It Was Always... Liverpool

It Was Always... Liverpool

Arne Slot and Liverpool: Respect, Reality and an Inevitable Decision

Why gratitude and hard truths must coexist at Anfield

Eddie Gibbs's avatar
Eddie Gibbs
Jan 19, 2026
∙ Paid
Upgrade to paid to play voiceover

There comes a point in every cycle when noise stops being noise and becomes something heavier. Not outrage, not panic, but recognition. That is where Liverpool find themselves now. Not collapsing, not drifting aimlessly in mid-table obscurity, but caught in a place far more uncomfortable. A place where belief has thinned, trust has eroded, and patience is being asked to stretch beyond its natural limits.

This piece is not written with anger, nor with abuse. I will never accept slurs aimed at Arne Slot. He won a league title for Liverpool. That alone grants him a permanent place in the club’s modern history. Respect is not negotiable. Gratitude is not optional.

But respect does not have to mean silence. Admiration does not require denial.

My view is clear, and it has been for some time. Liverpool should already have made a change. I do not say that lightly, and I do not say it with joy. I say it because everything I am watching, feeling, and hearing tells me the same thing. This cycle has run its course.

The purpose here is not to shout for the sake of shouting. It is to lay out how we got here, who carries responsibility, what direction the club appears to be heading in and why I believe the end point is already written, even if the timing is not.

Responsibility and fault lines at Liverpool

Liverpool’s current malaise does not sit neatly at the feet of one man. Anyone telling you otherwise is simplifying a complex, uncomfortable reality.

Start with the players. Too many have lost clarity under pressure. Too many moments where control evaporates once adversity arrives. Leads feel fragile. Confidence looks conditional. The moment Liverpool concedes, the structure collapses, and anxiety floods the pitch. That is not purely tactical. That is psychological.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of It was always....

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 It Was Always... Liverpool · Publisher Privacy ∙ Publisher Terms
Substack · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture