Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JA's avatar
5hEdited

It’s not all that simple.

Yes, selling players can recoup cost.

But, for example, keeping Trent and winning the league (which he was absolutely vital for) more than recoups the £40m (?) we could have got for selling him the summer before… and we have seen how hard he has been to replace.

… whatever some fan may say, Trent was 100% integral to our title win, as shown by our struggles this season…

Likewise, konate two summers ago… and again last summer… if he had maintained form and we had won big trophies 🤷‍♂️ it would have been worth the reduced fee he would have commanded with one year left.

As Ian Graham said in his book - if you get everything right, there is still on average a 50% failure rate on transfers.

So the sustainable business model is different between say Brighton, Brentford, Bournemouth, red bull and Liverpool..

Because we are not losing the players for free *if* they help you win trophies, or progress in CL etc and you recoup in bonuses.

The bitterness that we feel as fans doesn’t necessarily translate to the actual risk..

At Liverpools level.. the upside of letting a player run the contract down is the money you return from success..

.. and the additional risk is being tied to an absolutely massive contract and what that can do to your overall salary bill, ability to sign other players etc.

Now I genuinely don’t believe Trent leaving was about money; frankly he *was* massively undervalued by a lot of Liverpool fans, pundits, the UK press, England managers… but I don’t think for the second the LFC data nerds undervalued him.

I do believe he left for the change, the challenge, the lifestyle and to prove himself at another top club and get the respect he deserves.

Now konate… I do believe that’s due to money.. mainly because if the club wants to give konate a big deal, due to his injury record, to manage the risk.. the club may want a large amount of it performance/appearance based..

… and if you are a player with konates record you want bonuses not tied to appearance…

Szoboslai is a but different for me because despite his effort, I think Wirtz and grav have the ability to be better.. so there is potentially already cover in the team and is he first choice in anyone 1 position? 🤷‍♂️

Christian's avatar

A Liverpool player bails on a free, Liverpool gazump Newcastle for one of their targets.

So far, so 2025-2026.

3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?